Welcome to the world of College Re-alignment... the rivalries that have been killed sucks across the board, just ask the Big 12 ( no TEX or OK vs. Neb)....WVU in the Big 12 ?, Louisville, KY and Notre Dame in the "Atlantic Coast " Maryland out ?. But Uconn has bigger plans than the Big East and like I said this is more than about playing basketball in a conference where most teams don't even own the arena they play in.....
As Doc said Uconn needs a long term solution for all their sports.......Is the AAC ideal ?... no.. but they play FB at the highest level so it is what it is.......Cincy, Temple and Navy are fine for now as "local rivals".........The ones you mentioned the B1G ( which would be for all-sports including their Hockey team), ACC,or even the Big 12, since the travel is mostly the same as the AAC,
is the long term goal as a member of a P-5 conference. More movement from other schools in the P-5 is bound to happen which could be a good thing for Uconn, but they can't go backwards to the BE..... Uconn's AD has already talked about it being a non-starter.......especially when guys like former Marquette coach Buzz Williams is talking about the reason he left the Big East... that the
: P-5 could separate away completely in a few years, just as they have done in Football..... for basketball too.
The geography was killed along time ago when teams started leaving the real Big East back in 2003, finally including the catholic schools who left too. Uconn was the only original one who stayed ( it's the reason they ended up with millions in exit fee money)....Now the BE has Creighton (NE), Butler(IN) Marquette (WI), Depaul (IL) ??? ...not exactly "East" either. The lower AAC is weak but so were the bottom feeders in the BE for years...Uconn will be fine where ever they compete because they win championships and you asked about recruiting so that's self explanatory.
In the last 20 years there has been 13 BE appearances in the Final 4, 10/11 of those appearances are by teams no longer in the Big East. Uconn had 4 of them plus a 5th appearance as well as their 4th national championship coming out of the American in 2014. If you ask me it is the other way around, Uconn and a few others like Cuse and Ville saved the BE. And Nova's SR recruiting class was brought in to play in the Big East just like some of Uconn's NC team was a few years ago. So long term who knows ???
1996 Syracuse - Big East
1999 Connecticut - Big East
NC
2003 Syracuse- Big East
NC
2004 Connecticut- Big East
NC
2007
Georgetown- Big East
2009 Connecticut- Big East
......Villanova - Big East
2010 West Virginia- Big East
2011 Connecticut- Big East
NC
2012 Louisville- Big East
2013 Louisville- Big East
NC......Syracuse- Big East
2014 Connecticut - American
NC
2016
Villanova- Big East NC...... Syracuse- Atlantic Coast